P&C Insurance Agent Close Rate 2026
Updated 2026-03-04 · unLocked CRM Research
Direct Answer.
Average Property & Casualty insurance agent close rate on quoted prospects in 2026 is 22–35%. Auto + home bundle quotes close highest (38%). Standalone home insurance closes at 24%, standalone auto at 28%, commercial lines at 18%. Captive P&C agents close at the higher end of the range (28–35%) because of brand recognition; independents close at 22–30% but typically write higher-premium policies.
P&C close rates are heavily impacted by carrier appointment count. Independents with 6+ carrier appointments close 1.5–2× the rate of independents with 2–3 appointments because they can place harder-to-rate risks.
Bundle penetration is the largest lever. Agents who quote auto + home together close 38% of bundles vs. 24–28% on standalone quotes — and bundled accounts have 40% lower lifetime lapse rates.
Hard-market periods (2022–2025 in auto) compressed close rates 5–10 points industry-wide as carriers tightened underwriting. 2026 underwriting has loosened modestly, lifting average close rates 2–4 points.
Sources.
- Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (Big I) — Agency Universe Study, 2025
- unLocked CRM — Insurance Agent Technology Survey, Q1 2026 (n=2,847 licensed producers)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — Insurance Sales Agents Occupational Outlook
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is a good close rate for a P&C insurance agent?
- 22–35% on quoted prospects is industry average. 35%+ is top quartile. Bundle close rates run 38%.
- Why do bundle quotes close higher?
- Multi-line pricing discounts (10–25%) and the convenience of single-bill consolidation drive bundle close rates to 38% vs. 24–28% standalone.
- Do captive P&C agents close more than independents?
- Slightly — captive close rates run 28–35% vs. 22–30% for independents. Independents typically write higher-premium policies because they can place harder-to-rate risks.