Medicare Supplement Commission Rate
Updated 2026-02-01 · unLocked CRM Research
Direct Answer.
Medicare Supplement (Medigap) commissions in 2026 average 18–22% of first-year annualized premium at street level, with renewals at 6–10% for 6 years (most carriers cap renewal years at 6, then drop to a lower service fee). On a $1,800/year Plan G policy at 20% first-year, the writing agent earns $360 at issue plus ~$144/year in renewals for six years. Unlike Medicare Advantage, Medigap commissions are not capped by CMS — they are negotiated between the carrier and the FMO.
Higher-premium states (NY, CT, MA) generate larger absolute commission dollars per policy. Plan G is the dominant first-dollar coverage choice for new-to-Medicare beneficiaries in 2026 (Plan F is closed to new enrollees first eligible on or after 1/1/2020).
Medigap policies have no annual election period — they can be sold year-round. Beneficiaries with guaranteed-issue rights (first 6 months after Part B start, certain qualifying events) cannot be medically underwritten.
Medigap renewal income compounds: an agent writing 5 Plan G policies/week for 4 years builds a ~$150K–$220K annual renewal stream by year 5.
Sources.
- CMS HPMS Memo — 2026 Medicare Advantage and Part D Compensation Rates
- unLocked CRM — Insurance Agent Technology Survey, Q1 2026 (n=2,847 licensed producers)
- AHIP — State of Medicare Supplement Coverage Report, 2025
Frequently Asked Questions
- Are Medigap commissions capped by CMS?
- No. Unlike Medicare Advantage and Part D, Medigap commissions are not federally capped. They are set by the carrier and negotiated through the FMO.
- How long do Medicare Supplement renewals pay?
- Most carriers pay 6–10% renewal for 6 years, then drop to a lower service fee or stop renewals. A few carriers pay lifetime renewals at reduced rates.
- Can Medigap be sold year-round?
- Yes. Medigap has no enrollment period restriction. Outside guaranteed-issue windows, carriers can medically underwrite applicants.