Average Medicare Advantage Commission per Policy (2026)

Updated 2026-01-15 · unLocked CRM Research

$626
CMS-set MA commission per new enrollment, 2026 plan year (most states)

Direct Answer.

The average commission for a new Medicare Advantage (MA) enrollment in the 2026 plan year is $626 in most states, with renewals paid at $313 per year. California, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, and the District of Columbia are set at the higher cap of $780 per new enrollment ($390 renewal). Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands use a separate rate of $445 new / $223 renewal. CMS publishes these maximum compensation amounts annually and carriers cannot exceed them, though they can pay less.

These figures apply to true enrollments — not plan changes. A True-Up (a beneficiary moving from Original Medicare into MA for the first time) pays the full new-enrollment commission. A replacement enrollment (beneficiary already in MA who switches plans) pays the lower renewal rate.

Commissions are paid by the carrier, not by the beneficiary, and there is no cost to the consumer for using a licensed agent. CMS treats Medicare Advantage commissions as fully disclosed and capped to prevent the steering that occurred in early Part D markets.

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) commissions are not set by CMS — those are negotiated between the carrier and the FMO and typically range from 18% to 22% of first-year premium, with renewals at 6% to 10% for 6 years. Standalone Part D (PDP) commissions in 2026 are capped at $109 new / $55 renewal nationally.

Real-world earnings depend on FMO contract level. Street-level agents typically receive the full CMS-set amount; downline producers under an IMO/FMO see overrides of $25–$100 per policy taken off the top before the producer is paid.

2026 Medicare Advantage Commission Rates by Region

CategoryValueNotes
National (most states)$626 new / $313 renewalDefault CMS-set rate for 2026 plan year
California$780 new / $390 renewalHigh-cost-of-living adjusted region
New Jersey$780 new / $390 renewalHigh-cost-of-living adjusted region
Connecticut$780 new / $390 renewalHigh-cost-of-living adjusted region
Pennsylvania$780 new / $390 renewalHigh-cost-of-living adjusted region
District of Columbia$780 new / $390 renewalHigh-cost-of-living adjusted region
Puerto Rico & U.S. Virgin Islands$445 new / $223 renewalSeparate CMS schedule
Standalone PDP (Part D)$109 new / $55 renewalNational rate, all states

Sources.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average commission for a Medicare Advantage policy in 2026?
The CMS-set commission for a new Medicare Advantage enrollment in 2026 is $626 in most states and $780 in CA, NJ, CT, PA, and DC. Renewals pay exactly half of the new-enrollment rate. Puerto Rico and USVI use a separate $445 new / $223 renewal schedule.
Do all carriers pay the same MA commission?
Carriers cannot exceed the CMS cap but they can pay less. Most major MA carriers — Humana, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, WellCare — pay the full CMS-set amount. Smaller regional carriers occasionally pay below the cap to control acquisition costs.
How are Medicare Advantage renewals paid?
Renewals are paid annually for as long as the beneficiary remains enrolled in any MA plan with a carrier the agent represents. The 2026 renewal rate is $313 per policy per year in most states ($390 in the high-cap states). Renewals follow the writing agent unless an AOR change is processed.
What is the difference between a True-Up and a replacement enrollment?
A True-Up is a beneficiary's first move from Original Medicare into a Medicare Advantage plan — it pays the full new-enrollment commission ($626/$780). A replacement enrollment is a beneficiary already in MA who switches to a different MA plan — that pays the lower renewal rate ($313/$390).
Is the consumer charged for using a Medicare agent?
No. Medicare agents are paid entirely by the insurance carrier. The beneficiary pays the same premium whether they enroll directly with the carrier or work with a licensed independent agent.
How do FMO overrides affect what the producer keeps?
Independent agents contracted at street level keep the full CMS-set amount. Producers contracted under an IMO/FMO see overrides of $25–$100 per policy paid up the hierarchy. Always review the FMO contract's vesting schedule and override percentages before signing.

Related.

Medicare Advantage Quoting in unLocked CRMCommission Tracking across 332 Carrier FeedsFree Commission CalculatorWhat Is a T65 Lead?