Average Cost Per ACA Lead 2026
Updated 2026-02-05 · unLocked CRM Research
Direct Answer.
ACA marketplace lead costs in 2026 range from $4 per shared internet lead to $45+ per inbound warm transfer. Exclusive internet leads run $12–$22. Spanish-language ACA leads are 20–35% cheaper than English-language and convert at comparable or higher rates for bilingual agents. OEP-season pricing (Nov 1 – Jan 15) runs 40–80% higher than off-season because of competitive bidding.
ACA's PMPM commission model rewards lead volume more than per-policy commission size. A family-of-four enrollment at $25 PMPM generates $1,200/year in recurring commission — supporting much higher CPAs than per-policy Medicare leads.
Bilingual (English + Spanish) agents have a structural advantage in ACA because 30%+ of marketplace enrollees are Spanish-preferred. Spanish-language leads convert at 1.3–1.8× the rate of English leads for bilingual producers.
Off-OEP, Special Enrollment Period (SEP) leads driven by qualifying life events (job loss, marriage, birth, move) are the highest-converting source. Volume is lower but close rates are 2–3× OEP shared-internet leads.
Sources.
- HealthSherpa — ACA Lead Performance Benchmarks, 2026 OEP
- unLocked CRM — Insurance Agent Technology Survey, Q1 2026 (n=2,847 licensed producers)
- CMS — ACA Marketplace Open Enrollment Public Use File
Frequently Asked Questions
- How much does an ACA lead cost?
- $4–$45 depending on source. Shared internet $4–$10, exclusive $12–$22, inbound warm transfer $25–$45.
- Are Spanish ACA leads cheaper?
- Yes — typically 20–35% cheaper than English-language. Bilingual agents see 1.3–1.8× the conversion rate, making them the highest-ROI source for bilingual producers.
- When is the cheapest time to buy ACA leads?
- Off-OEP (Feb–Oct). SEP-driven leads are lower-volume but convert at 2–3× the rate of OEP shared-internet leads.