Average Renewal Commission Rate
Updated 2026-02-12 · unLocked CRM Research
Direct Answer.
Insurance renewal commissions in 2026 vary by product. Term life pays 1–3% of premium years 2–10. Whole life and IUL pay 2–5%. Medigap pays 6–10% for years 2–7. ACA pays the same PMPM rate as year one for as long as the member stays enrolled. Medicare Advantage pays a $313 per user ($390 in CA/NJ/CT/PA/DC) per renewal year. P&C lines typically pay flat 10–15% of premium for all years.
Renewals are the single largest determinant of long-term agent income. An agent with a 500-policy mature renewal book typically generates $40K–$120K in passive annual income before writing a single new policy.
Vesting matters. Independent agents at street-level contracts typically own renewals from day one. Captive agents often face graded vesting (e.g., 25% per year, 100% vested after 4 years) and may forfeit renewals if they leave early.
Renewals are protected from chargeback after the chargeback window expires (typically 12–18 months on life). After that, lapse only reduces forward-looking renewal income; it does not claw back paid commission.
Sources.
- CMS HPMS Memo — 2026 Medicare Advantage and Part D Compensation Rates
- LIMRA — U.S. Individual Life Insurance Sales Survey, 2025–2026
- unLocked CRM — Insurance Agent Technology Survey, Q1 2026 (n=2,847 licensed producers)
Frequently Asked Questions
- How are insurance renewal commissions paid?
- Renewal commissions are paid by the carrier as the policyholder pays each renewal premium. Most carriers pay renewals monthly as premium is collected.
- Do agents keep renewals if they leave an agency?
- Depends on the contract. Independent street-level contracts vest renewals from day one. Captive contracts often have graded vesting that requires 3–5 years before renewals are fully owned.
- Which product has the best renewal economics?
- Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and ACA produce the strongest long-term renewal streams. Medigap pays 6–10% for 6 years; ACA pays the same PMPM rate for the life of the enrollment.