Average Renewal Commission Rate

Updated 2026-02-12 · unLocked CRM Research

1–10%
of annualized premium paid as renewal commission across U.S. insurance product types (2026)

Direct Answer.

Insurance renewal commissions in 2026 vary by product. Term life pays 1–3% of premium years 2–10. Whole life and IUL pay 2–5%. Medigap pays 6–10% for years 2–7. ACA pays the same PMPM rate as year one for as long as the member stays enrolled. Medicare Advantage pays a $313 per user ($390 in CA/NJ/CT/PA/DC) per renewal year. P&C lines typically pay flat 10–15% of premium for all years.

Renewals are the single largest determinant of long-term agent income. An agent with a 500-policy mature renewal book typically generates $40K–$120K in passive annual income before writing a single new policy.

Vesting matters. Independent agents at street-level contracts typically own renewals from day one. Captive agents often face graded vesting (e.g., 25% per year, 100% vested after 4 years) and may forfeit renewals if they leave early.

Renewals are protected from chargeback after the chargeback window expires (typically 12–18 months on life). After that, lapse only reduces forward-looking renewal income; it does not claw back paid commission.

Sources.

Frequently Asked Questions

How are insurance renewal commissions paid?
Renewal commissions are paid by the carrier as the policyholder pays each renewal premium. Most carriers pay renewals monthly as premium is collected.
Do agents keep renewals if they leave an agency?
Depends on the contract. Independent street-level contracts vest renewals from day one. Captive contracts often have graded vesting that requires 3–5 years before renewals are fully owned.
Which product has the best renewal economics?
Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and ACA produce the strongest long-term renewal streams. Medigap pays 6–10% for 6 years; ACA pays the same PMPM rate for the life of the enrollment.

Related.

Commission tracking across 332 carrier feeds