Average Medicare AEP Volume per Agent
Updated 2026-01-20 · unLocked CRM Research
Direct Answer.
The average independent Medicare agent writes 35–60 new enrollments during the 7-week Annual Election Period (AEP, October 15 – December 7). Top producers (top 10%) write 200–500. Daily volume during AEP typically runs 2–5 applications/day for an average producer and 10–20+ for top producers using AI quoting, AI receptionists, and pre-AEP T65 pipeline automation.
Pre-AEP pipeline preparation is the largest predictor of AEP volume. Agents who enter October with 100+ pre-qualified T65 prospects routinely 2–3× their close volume versus agents starting cold.
AI-assisted quoting and electronic application submission (vs. paper Scope of Appointment + phone-call enrollment) has cut average enrollment time from 45 minutes to 12–15 minutes per application, allowing top producers to double their daily AEP cap.
Compliance overhead — 48-hour SOA cooling period, recorded calls, AHIP recertification — eats roughly 6–10 hours/week during AEP for the average producer.
Sources.
- CMS HPMS Memo — 2026 Medicare Advantage and Part D Compensation Rates
- unLocked CRM — Insurance Agent Technology Survey, Q1 2026 (n=2,847 licensed producers)
- Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (Big I) — Agency Universe Study, 2025
Frequently Asked Questions
- How many Medicare enrollments does an agent write during AEP?
- Average independent agents write 35–60 new enrollments during AEP. Top 10% write 200–500.
- How long does each Medicare enrollment take?
- Electronic applications with AI-assisted quoting average 12–15 minutes. Paper applications and phone-only enrollment workflows average 35–45 minutes.
- What separates top AEP producers from average?
- Pre-AEP T65 pipeline (100+ qualified prospects entering October), AI-assisted quoting, electronic SOA + e-app, and an inbound AI receptionist handling overflow calls.