How to Sell Medicare Advantage

From your health license to your first 200 enrollments — the licensing, AHIP, certification, lead, and compliance playbook independent Medicare Advantage agents actually use.

Updated June 2026 22 min read

Step 1: Get Your Health Insurance License

Medicare Advantage is a health line, so it starts with a resident health insurance producer license in your home state. Most agents pair the life line onto the same exam to open up cross-sell.

01Pre-licensing course

20–40 hours, online or in person, depending on your state.

02State exam

Scheduled through Prometric, PSI, or Pearson VUE.

03Background check & fingerprinting

Required in most states.

04License application

Filed through NIPR for roughly $50–$200.

05NPN issued

Your National Producer Number follows you across every state and carrier.

Add non-resident licenses in any state you intend to write. Medicare leads cross state lines constantly, and writing without the resident state's license is a CMS violation.

Step 2: Pass AHIP and Carrier Certifications

No carrier will let you write an MA application until you clear AHIP certification for the coming plan year, then each carrier's own product module.

AHIP exam

~$175, often ~$125 via your FMO

Covers Medicare basics, fraud/waste/abuse, and marketing rules. 90% passing score, up to three attempts.

Carrier certifications

2–4 hours each

Humana, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, Cigna, Wellcare, Anthem, and the regional Blues each run their own module.

Annual recertification

June–August, every year

Required ahead of the October 1 marketing window.

Aim to be ready-to-sell with at least 4–6 carriers before October 15. Agents who certify with one carrier leave 60%+ of plan options off the table for their clients.

Step 3: Contract Through an FMO

Independent MA agents contract through an FMO or IMO rather than direct with the carrier. The FMO handles contracting and certifications and provides the multi-carrier quoting and enrollment tools.

Top-of-street commission

2026: ~$626 / ~$313

CMS sets MA initial and renewal comp annually. Your FMO should pass full street, not a haircut.

Open release policy

No six-month captive periods holding you in place.

AHIP discount

Most reputable FMOs cover or discount your AHIP fee.

Carrier breadth

At minimum the big six — Humana, UHC, Aetna, Cigna, Wellcare, Anthem — plus the regional carriers in your footprint.

Technology included

CMS-compliant SOA, multi-carrier quoting, an enrollment platform, and renewal tracking.

Step 4: Build a Compliant Lead Engine

Medicare marketing is the most regulated lead-gen channel in insurance. CMS Marketing Guidelines govern how leads are generated, scripted, and contacted.

T65 direct mail

Highest intent, highest cost

Targeted at people turning 65 in the next three to six months.

Aged Medicare leads

Lower cost, run at volume

Lower cost per lead; run them at volume through the Power Dialer and Agent AI.

Community events & seminars

Must be filed with CMS

You cannot pitch specific plans without prior permission to contact.

Client referrals

Highest close rate

Allowed without PTC, because the prospect initiates the contact.

Provider partnerships

Steady and local

Doctors' offices and SNFs that need help guiding patients toward MA plans.

The T65 Pipeline

The most predictable Medicare books run on a 6–12 month T65 pipeline: identify aging-in prospects early, nurture with educational content, and enroll during their Initial Enrollment Period. Manual T65 tracking breaks down past about 50 prospects — automation is the only way to scale it.

Step 5: Run Every Appointment Through SOA

The Scope of Appointment is the most-audited document in Medicare sales. CMS requires a signed SOA before any appointment where MA, PDP, or MAPD will be discussed — retained for 10 years.

The 48-hour rule

SOA collected at least 48 hours ahead, unless the beneficiary is within four days of an enrollment deadline or walks into your office.

The 12-hour gap

For anything not in person, the SOA must be on file at least 12 hours before the presentation.

Call recording

Every inbound and outbound Medicare sales call recorded and retained for 10 years.

Transcript retention

CMS expects searchable transcripts, not just the audio file.

Remote SOA

A secure signature link valid for seven days — see the Remote SOA workflow.

Non-compliance is the number one reason agents lose carrier appointments. Build SOA and call recording into the workflow on day one; bolting them on later means re-doing every active client file.

Step 6: Quote Every Case Across Every Carrier

MA plans change every year — formularies, networks, MOOPs, premiums, supplemental benefits. A plan that fit last year can cost thousands more this year. The agents who retain clients are the ones who shop every plan, every AEP.

Drug formulary matching

Pull the client's Rx list and rank plans by total annual drug cost.

Provider network matching

Confirm PCPs and specialists are in-network before you enroll anyone.

Supplemental benefit comparison

Dental, vision, OTC, transportation, and flex cards side by side.

Star ratings & MOOP

Surface 4+ star plans carrying lower out-of-pocket limits.

The AI Quoting Suite integrates HealthSherpa for enrollment and runs MA, MAPD, PDP, and Med Supp side by side across your whole panel, then auto-builds the e-application.

Step 7: Win AEP, Keep the Book

MA renews every January 1, and from October 15 to December 7 every one of your clients is being marketed to by every other agent. Retention is won in the nine months before AEP, not during it.

September annual review

With every active client: formulary, network, premium, MOOP.

Cost increase alerts

Fire when a client's plan jumps more than 10% — see the Renewal Dashboard.

OEP awareness

January 1 to March 31 lets MA enrollees switch once. Most clients have no idea.

SEP tracking

Moves, LIS changes, and dual-eligible status all open special election periods.

Annual review PDF

A branded recap of what changed, what did not, and why the plan still fits. See Medicare Annual Reviews.

A retained MA client is worth $313 a year for eight-plus years on renewals alone. Agents holding 90%+ retention on books of 500+ clear well above $150K a year in renewals before writing a single new application.

Step 8: Run Your Practice on a Real Tech Stack

You cannot run a compliant, scalable Medicare practice on spreadsheets and a Gmail inbox. The agents writing 200+ enrollments per AEP all run the same core stack.

Multi-carrier MA/MAPD/PDP quoting

With formulary and provider lookup built into the quote.

HealthSherpa-integrated enrollment

End-to-end e-applications without leaving the workflow.

CMS-compliant SOA

Remote signing plus the 10-year retention CMS expects.

Call recording & transcripts

For every Medicare sales call, searchable rather than archived audio.

T65 pipeline automation

Aging-in tracking across a 6–12 month horizon.

Renewal dashboard

Cost-increase alerts and revenue-at-risk reporting.

Commission tracking

Across every carrier, with chargeback reconciliation.

unLocked CRM bundles every layer above into one platform built for Medicare, ACA, life, and annuity agents. Start a free 14-day trial and quote your first Medicare case in under two minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to start selling Medicare Advantage?+
Plan on 6–10 weeks from zero to ready-to-sell: 2–4 weeks for your health license, 1–2 weeks for AHIP, and 2–4 weeks for carrier certifications and FMO contracting. Time it so you're RTS by October 1 for AEP.
How much can a Medicare Advantage agent make?+
CMS-set 2026 comp is approximately $626 initial and $313 renewal per enrollment in most states. Agents writing 150–250 new enrollments per AEP plus a renewal book of 500+ commonly earn $200K–$400K annually.
Do I have to record every Medicare sales call?+
Yes. CMS requires that every inbound and outbound Medicare sales call be recorded and retained for 10 years, including searchable transcripts. This applies to TPMOs and downstream agents alike.
What is a Scope of Appointment (SOA) and when do I need one?+
An SOA is a CMS-required document that limits a sales appointment to the specific Medicare products the beneficiary agreed to discuss. You must collect it before the appointment — generally at least 48 hours in advance — and retain it for 10 years.
Can I sell Medicare Advantage in multiple states?+
Yes, but you need a non-resident health license in every state where you write and you must be carrier-appointed in those states. unLocked tracks license and appointment status by state automatically.
What's the difference between AEP, OEP, and SEPs?+
AEP (Oct 15 – Dec 7) is the Annual Election Period when anyone with Medicare can change plans. OEP (Jan 1 – Mar 31) lets MA enrollees switch once. SEPs are Special Enrollment Periods triggered by life events like moves, loss of coverage, or dual-eligible status.

Related Deep Dives

Ready to See It in Action?

Start your 14-day free trial. No contract required.