TCPA violations cost $500–$1,500 per call. Here's what every insurance agent needs to know about call timing, consent requirements.
TL;DR
TCPA violations cost $500–$1,500 per call/text. Key requirements: no calls before 8 AM or after 9 PM (recipient's time zone), prior express written consent for automated outreach, one-to-one consent for purchased leads, and 10DLC registration for SMS. Purpose-built insurance CRMs enforce these rules automatically.
Key Data Points
- TCPA violations cost $500–$1,500 per non-compliant call or text. A single 1,000-text campaign without proper consent could generate $500,000–$1,500,000 in liability.
- The FCC's one-to-one consent rule requires leads be consented to a single named seller — fundamentally changing how insurance agents purchase and use leads.
The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) is the most financially dangerous compliance area for insurance agents. Violations cost $500–$1,500 per call or text, and class-action lawsuits against insurance agencies have resulted in settlements exceeding $10 million.
This guide covers what insurance agents must know in 2026.
Core TCPA Requirements
Call Timing Restrictions
- No calls before 8:00 AM in the recipient's local time zone
- No calls after 9:00 PM in the recipient's local time zone
- Time zone management — agents calling across time zones must track each recipient's location
- State-specific rules — some states have stricter windows (e.g., no calls after 8 PM)
Consent Requirements
Prior Express Written Consent (PEWC)
Required for:
- Autodialed calls to cell phones
- Pre-recorded voice messages to cell phones
- Automated text messages
PEWC must be:
- In writing (digital signatures count)
- Clearly disclosed — the consumer knows they are consenting to calls/texts
- Not a condition of purchase — cannot require consent to buy insurance
- Specific to your business — cannot use consent obtained by a different company
The 2025 FCC One-to-One Consent Rule
The FCC's updated rule requires:
- Consent must be to a single seller — no more lead generators selling consent to multiple agents
- Consent must specify the seller by name
- Lead forms must clearly identify which company will be calling
This dramatically impacts lead purchasing. Agents buying leads must verify that consent was obtained specifically for their agency.
Do-Not-Call Compliance
- Check the National DNC Registry before calling any prospect
- Maintain an internal DNC list — anyone who requests no further calls
- Honor opt-outs immediately — within 30 days maximum, preferably instantly
- Document DNC requests with timestamps in your CRM
10DLC Registration for SMS
All business text messaging requires 10DLC (10-Digit Long Code) registration:
- Brand registration — register your business with The Campaign Registry
- Campaign registration — register each type of messaging campaign
- Content restrictions — messages must match registered campaign purposes
- Throughput limits — sending volume is limited based on trust score
Insurance-Specific TCPA Risks
Medicare Outreach
CMS rules layer on top of TCPA for Medicare marketing:
- No unsolicited calls to Medicare beneficiaries about Medicare products
- SOA required before any plan-specific discussion
- Event-specific rules for educational vs. marketing events
- Permission-based contact — beneficiary must initiate or give prior consent
Lead Source Compliance
- Verify consent documentation for every purchased lead
- Audit lead providers — request sample consent forms and disclosure language
- Reject shared leads — leads sold to multiple agents likely violate one-to-one consent rules
- Document everything — maintain records of lead source and consent for each prospect
How CRM Technology Enforces TCPA
Modern insurance CRMs should enforce TCPA automatically:
- Automated quiet hours — calls and texts blocked outside permitted windows per recipient time zone
- Consent tracking — record and verify consent status before any automated outreach
- DNC integration — automatic checking against National DNC Registry and internal lists
- 10DLC management — registered campaigns with content compliance
- Audit trail — complete record of all communications with timestamps and consent documentation
TCPA Violation Penalties
Violation Type — Penalty
Non-willful violation — $500 per call/text
Willful/knowing violation — $1,500 per call/text
Class action (typical) — $1M–$10M+
Individual lawsuit — $10,000–$100,000+
A single campaign of 1,000 non-compliant texts could result in $500,000–$1,500,000 in liability.
FAQ
How much can TCPA violations cost an insurance agent?
$500–$1,500 per non-compliant call or text. A campaign of 1,000 texts without proper consent could cost $500,000–$1,500,000. Class-action settlements often exceed $10 million.
What is the one-to-one consent rule?
The FCC's updated rule requires that consumer consent for automated calls/texts be specific to a single identified seller — not shared across multiple companies through lead generators.
Do I need 10DLC registration to text clients?
Yes. All business SMS messaging requires 10DLC registration including brand registration, campaign registration, and content compliance.
How do I know if my leads have proper consent?
Request consent documentation from your lead provider showing that the consumer specifically agreed to be contacted by your agency, that consent was not a condition of purchase, and that the consent form clearly identified your business.
From Experience
- Agents using CRMs without automated TCPA quiet hours enforcement are the highest-risk group for violations — manual time zone management at scale is unreliable.
- The one-to-one consent rule has effectively eliminated the shared-lead model — agents buying shared leads face significant TCPA exposure.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can TCPA violations cost?
$500–$1,500 per call/text. 1,000 non-compliant texts = $500K–$1.5M liability. Class actions exceed $10M.
What is the one-to-one consent rule?
Consumer consent must be specific to a single identified seller — not shared across multiple companies.
Do I need 10DLC registration?
Yes — all business SMS requires brand registration, campaign registration, and content compliance.
How do I verify lead consent?
Request documentation showing consumer agreed to be contacted by your specific agency.
What are TCPA quiet hours for insurance agents?
No calls or texts before 8 AM or after 9 PM in the recipient's local time zone. Some states have stricter windows — always check state-specific rules.
Can I text clients without written consent?
Transactional texts (appointment reminders, policy updates) require express consent. Marketing texts require express written consent — a higher legal bar with documented opt-in.
What is the difference between express consent and express written consent?
Express consent allows informational texts and can be verbal. Express written consent is required for marketing/sales texts and must be documented (web form, paper, or e-signature).
How do I stay TCPA compliant with purchased leads?
Under the one-to-one consent rule, leads must have consented specifically to your named business. Shared or multi-seller leads do not satisfy TCPA requirements.
Does my CRM handle TCPA compliance automatically?
Purpose-built insurance CRMs enforce quiet hours, track consent status, manage DNC lists, and maintain audit trails automatically. Generic CRMs typically do not.