The first 10 seconds of a power dialer call determine everything. Here are proven scripts for insurance openers, objection handling, and appointment setting.
TL;DR
Power dialer scripts for insurance agents must accomplish three things in the first 10 seconds: identify yourself, reference why you're calling, and ask a permission question. Objection handling should use curiosity questions (not pushback), and every call should aim for a specific appointment time rather than a vague 'I'll follow up.'
What Is Insurance Cold Call Script?
A structured conversation framework for power dialer sessions that includes a 10-second opener (identify, reference, permission), objection handling responses, appointment-setting closes, and voicemail drop scripts — designed for the speed and volume of automated dialing.
Key Data Points
- The first 10 seconds of a cold call determine whether the prospect stays on the line — agents who use a structured opener convert 2.5x more calls to conversations.
- Responding to 'just send me an email' with two qualifying questions before hanging up converts 35% of those prospects into appointments.
Power dialing is a numbers game — but the numbers only work when the conversations are effective. An agent with a 25% connect rate and a strong script will set more appointments than an agent with a 25% connect rate and no script.
The scripts below are designed for the speed and context of power dialer sessions: short, direct, and focused on setting appointments rather than closing on the first call.
Opening Scripts (First 10 Seconds)
The opener must accomplish three things in under 10 seconds:
- Identify yourself
- Reference why you are calling (their inquiry)
- Ask a permission question
Generic Lead Follow-Up
"Hi [Name], this is [Agent] with [Agency]. You recently requested information about [product] — I've put together some options for you. Do you have about 5 minutes?"
Medicare Lead
"Hi [Name], this is [Agent]. I'm calling about the Medicare information you requested. I specialize in helping folks in [county/area] find the best plan for their medications and doctors. Can I ask you a couple quick questions?"
Life Insurance Lead
"Hi [Name], this is [Agent] with [Agency]. You were looking into life insurance options — I work with over 40 carriers and can show you the best rates for your situation. Do you have a few minutes?"
Referral Call
"Hi [Name], this is [Agent]. [Referrer Name] suggested I give you a call — they mentioned you might be looking for help with [product]. Do you have a couple minutes?"
Callback (Previously Spoke)
"Hi [Name], it's [Agent] calling back as we discussed. I have your [product] quotes ready — do you have 10 minutes to review them?"
Objection Handling Scripts
"I'm not interested."
"Totally understand. Out of curiosity — do you already have [product] coverage in place, or is it more of a timing thing?"
If they have coverage: "Great — when was the last time you compared rates? Things change every year and I often find savings for people who haven't shopped recently. Would you be open to a quick comparison?"
If it's timing: "No problem at all. When would be a better time for me to reach out? I'll put it on my calendar."
"I'm busy right now."
"Completely understand — I know I'm catching you cold. Would [specific day/time] work for a quick 10-minute call? I'll have everything prepared so we make the most of your time."
"Just send me an email."
"Happy to! I'll send over a summary right after we hang up. Before I do — can I ask two quick questions so I can tailor what I send? It'll take 30 seconds."
(Then ask qualifying questions and still try to set an appointment at the end.)
"How did you get my number?"
"You submitted a request for [product] information on [date/source]. I'm following up on that inquiry. Would you like to continue, or would you prefer I remove your information?"
"I'm already working with an agent."
"That's great — having an agent you trust is important. I'm not trying to replace them. But if you ever want a second opinion or want to compare options, I'm here. Can I at least send you my contact info in case anything changes?"
"Your price is too high."
"I hear you. The rates I quoted are based on the information we discussed — but rates vary a lot by carrier. If you're seeing a lower rate elsewhere, I'd love to take a look and make sure we're comparing apples to apples. Can you tell me what you've been quoted?"
Appointment-Setting Scripts
The Direct Close
"Based on what you've told me, I think I can find you [better coverage / lower rates / the right plan]. I'd love to set up a 15-minute call to walk through your options. Would [day/time] or [day/time] work better?"
The Value Close
"Here's what I'd like to do: I'll compare [X]+ carriers for you, put together a side-by-side comparison, and walk you through exactly what each option covers and costs. The whole thing takes about 15 minutes. When works best — morning or afternoon?"
The Urgency Close (Time-Sensitive)
"[AEP/OEP/rate change] is coming up on [date], and I want to make sure you have time to review your options before then. Can we schedule 20 minutes this week?"
Voicemail Drop Scripts
General
"Hi [Name], this is [Agent] with [Agency], calling about the [product] information you requested. I have some great options to share with you. My number is [number] — or just text me back at this number and I'll send over a summary. Talk soon."
Follow-Up
"[Name], it's [Agent] following up — I've been trying to connect with you about your [product] options. I've got your quotes ready and they look really good. Give me a call at [number] or reply to the text I'm about to send. Hope to hear from you."
Post-Call Disposition Notes
Quick notes save future-you enormous time. After each meaningful call, add a 1-2 sentence note:
- Interested: "Wants term 20, $500K. Spouse also needs coverage. Appt set for Thu 2pm."
- Callback: "At work, asked to call back after 5pm Wednesday. Interested in Medicare Supp."
- Not Interested: "Has coverage through employer. Revisit if they change jobs — works at [company]."
- Objection: "Price-sensitive. Getting quotes from [competitor]. Wants to compare — send follow-up comparison email."
From Experience
- The single most effective script change we've seen is replacing 'Do you have a minute?' with 'Do you have about 5 minutes?' Specificity implies you respect their time and have something prepared — answer rates on the permission question jump by 20%.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I say when a prospect answers a power dialer call?
Identify yourself, reference their inquiry, and ask permission: 'Hi [Name], this is [Agent] with [Agency]. You recently requested [product] information — I've put together some options. Do you have about 5 minutes?'
How do I handle 'I'm not interested' on a cold call?
Respond with curiosity, not pushback: 'Totally understand. Do you already have coverage in place, or is it more of a timing thing?' This re-opens 30-40% of initial objections.