MYGA vs. FIA: Which Fixed Annuity Is Right for Your Client?

Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities and Fixed Indexed Annuities serve different needs. Here's the definitive comparison to help agents match the right product.

TL;DR

MYGAs offer guaranteed fixed rates (4.5–5.5% in 2026) for 3–7 year terms. FIAs link returns to market indices with a 0% floor and offer income riders for 7+ year horizons.

Fixed annuities are the fastest-growing segment in insurance, with $300+ billion in annual sales. Two products dominate: MYGAs and FIAs.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature — MYGA — FIA

Interest Rate — Fixed & guaranteed — Variable (index-linked)

Downside Protection — Full guarantee — 0% floor (no market loss)

Typical Surrender Period — 3–7 years — 7–12 years

Commission to Agent — 1–3% — 4–7%

Best For — Safety-first clients — Growth-oriented conservative clients

When to Recommend a MYGA

MYGAs are ideal for clients who want guaranteed returns with zero complexity, have a specific time horizon (3–7 years), or are moving money from CDs.

In 2026, competitive MYGA rates range from 4.5% to 5.5% for 5-year terms.

When to Recommend a FIA

FIAs are ideal for clients who want growth potential beyond fixed rates, cannot stomach market losses, have a longer time horizon (7+ years), or need guaranteed lifetime income via riders.

FAQ

Can a client own both?

Yes — many advisors recommend laddering MYGAs for short-term and FIAs for longer-term growth potential.

Which pays higher commissions?

FIAs (4–7%) vs MYGAs (1–3%). Always recommend based on suitability.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can clients own both?

Yes — laddering MYGAs for short-term and FIAs for long-term growth is common.

Which pays higher commissions?

FIAs (4–7%) vs MYGAs (1–3%). Always recommend based on suitability.