Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity (MYGA) Sales Guide: The Simple Annuity Clients Love

MYGAs are the easiest annuity to explain and sell. Fixed rates, simple terms, and CD-beating returns. Here's the complete guide.

TL;DR

MYGA sales exceeded $58B in 2025. 2026 5-year rates: 4.5–5.5% vs CD 3.5–4.2%. Tax-deferred advantage: $200K at 5% for 5 years = $15,600 more than a taxable CD. Simplest annuity to explain and sell.

Key Data Points

  • MYGA sales exceeded $58 billion in 2025
  • 2026 MYGA 5-year rates range 4.5–5.5% vs CD rates of 3.5–4.2%
  • Tax-deferred MYGA earns $15,600 more than a taxable CD on $200K over 5 years
  • MYGAs are the simplest annuity product to explain and sell

MYGA Sales Guide

Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities are the simplest annuity product to explain, sell, and service. They work like CDs but with higher rates, tax-deferred growth, and insurance company guarantees. MYGA sales exceeded $58 billion in 2025.

How MYGAs Work

  • Client deposits a lump sum (typically $25K–$500K+)
  • Carrier guarantees a fixed interest rate for a set term (3, 5, 7, or 10 years)
  • Interest grows tax-deferred (no annual 1099)
  • At term end: renew, withdraw, or 1035 exchange
  • Protected by state insurance guaranty associations

MYGA vs. CD Comparison

Feature — MYGA — Bank CD

5-Year Rate (2026) — 4.5–5.5% — 3.5–4.2%

Tax Treatment — Tax-deferred — Taxed annually

FDIC/Guaranty — State guaranty (varies) — FDIC $250K

Early Withdrawal — Surrender charges — Early withdrawal penalty

Minimum — $10K–$25K — $500–$1K

Sales Positioning

Target clients: Conservative savers with CD maturities, retirees seeking guaranteed rates, tax-conscious investors wanting deferral.

The conversation: "Your CD is maturing at 3.8%. I can show you a guaranteed 5.2% for 5 years with the same safety — plus you won't pay taxes on the interest until you withdraw it. Want to see how much more you'd earn?"

Tax advantage illustration: $200K at 5% for 5 years. CD (taxed at 24%): grows to $239,700. MYGA (tax-deferred): grows to $255,300. Difference: $15,600 more with MYGA.

Compliance Notes

  • MYGAs are insurance products, not bank products — explain guaranty association vs. FDIC
  • Suitability documentation required (NAIC best interest standard)
  • Surrender charge schedule must be clearly disclosed
  • Not suitable for funds needed before term end

MYGA vs. Bank CD (2026)

Feature — MYGA — Bank CD

5-Year Rate — 4.5–5.5% — 3.5–4.2%

Tax Treatment — Tax-deferred — Taxed annually

Protection — State guaranty — FDIC $250K

Minimum — $10K–$25K — $500–$1K

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a MYGA annuity?

Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity — a fixed-rate annuity with guaranteed interest for 3–10 years, tax-deferred growth, and insurance company backing. Works like a CD but with higher rates.

Are MYGAs better than CDs?

MYGAs typically offer 1–1.5% higher rates than CDs with tax-deferred growth. A $200K MYGA earns $15,600 more than a CD over 5 years due to tax deferral.