Medicare Supplement Underwriting: Tips for Getting Clients Approved

Medigap underwriting is the biggest barrier to sales. Learn which conditions get declined, how to find guaranteed issue opportunities.

TL;DR

Medigap underwriting is required outside guaranteed issue periods. Common declines: COPD with oxygen, insulin diabetes with complications, recent cancer/heart attack/stroke. Pre-qualify clients before submitting. Try multiple carriers — guidelines vary significantly.

Key Data Points

  • Agents who master Medigap underwriting close 40% more supplement policies
  • Controlled Type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and sleep apnea usually pass Medigap underwriting
  • Each Medigap carrier has different underwriting criteria — always try multiple carriers

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) is the only Medicare product with medical underwriting outside of guaranteed issue periods. Agents who master underwriting knowledge close 40% more Medigap policies.

When Underwriting Applies

Guaranteed Issue (No Underwriting):

  • Medigap Open Enrollment Period (first 6 months after Part B starts at age 65+)
  • Loss of employer coverage
  • Medicare Advantage plan leaves the area
  • Certain trial rights (trying MA for the first time)

Underwritten (Health Questions Required):

  • Any application outside guaranteed issue periods
  • Under-65 disabled Medicare beneficiaries (in most states)
  • Plan upgrades (Plan G to Plan F, for example — though F is closed to new Medicare beneficiaries)

Common Declinable Conditions

Most carriers will decline or rate-up for:

  • COPD/emphysema requiring oxygen
  • Insulin-dependent diabetes with complications
  • Cancer treatment within 2–5 years (varies by carrier)
  • Heart attack or stroke within 2–3 years
  • Kidney dialysis
  • ALS, MS, Parkinson's (most carriers)
  • Organ transplant within 5 years

Conditions That Usually Pass

Surprisingly, many conditions agents assume are declinable actually pass:

  • Controlled Type 2 diabetes (no insulin, A1C under 8)
  • Controlled high blood pressure
  • History of cancer 5+ years ago with no recurrence
  • Joint replacement (6+ months post-surgery)
  • Controlled thyroid conditions
  • Sleep apnea with CPAP
  • Controlled depression/anxiety

Pre-Qualification Strategies

  1. Ask the right questions upfront: Use a pre-qualification questionnaire before submitting
  2. Know carrier-specific guidelines: Each carrier has different underwriting criteria
  3. Try multiple carriers: If one declines, another may approve
  4. Use preliminary applications: Some carriers offer pre-screening without a formal decline on record
  5. Check guaranteed issue eligibility: Many clients qualify and don't know it
  6. Consider alternative products: If Medigap fails, Medicare Advantage has no underwriting

The Pre-Qualification Questionnaire

Ask these before submitting any Medigap application:

  • Any cancer diagnosis or treatment in the past 5 years?
  • Currently using oxygen or on dialysis?
  • Any heart attack, stroke, or TIA in the past 3 years?
  • Currently taking insulin?
  • Any neurological conditions (MS, ALS, Parkinson's)?
  • Any upcoming surgeries scheduled?
  • Currently in a hospital, nursing facility, or hospice?

unLocked CRM includes pre-qualification workflows that match client health profiles to carrier underwriting guidelines, identifying the best carriers to submit to and flagging guaranteed issue opportunities automatically.

Frequently Asked Questions

When is Medicare Supplement underwriting required?

Any Medigap application outside guaranteed issue periods requires medical underwriting. GI periods include the first 6 months after Part B at 65+, loss of employer coverage, and MA plan leaving the area.

What health conditions are declined for Medigap?

Common declines include COPD requiring oxygen, insulin-dependent diabetes with complications, cancer treatment within 2–5 years, recent heart attack/stroke, dialysis, and neurological conditions like ALS or Parkinson's.