The Open Enrollment Period (January 1 – March 31) is the second chance most agents ignore. Here is how to use it strategically.
TL;DR
The Medicare OEP (January 1 – March 31) allows MA beneficiaries one plan change. 12-18% of MA enrollees make changes during OEP. Smart agents use this period for client retention check-ins and competitive prospecting.
Key Data Points
- 12-18% of Medicare Advantage enrollees make plan changes during OEP (January 1 – March 31).
- Agents who conduct post-AEP check-ins in January retain 23% more clients than those who wait for clients to call.
Most Medicare agents collapse after AEP. They are exhausted from 54 days of intense activity, and January feels like a time to rest. That is a strategic mistake.
The Medicare Open Enrollment Period (OEP) runs from January 1 through March 31. During OEP, Medicare Advantage beneficiaries can make one plan change — switching to a different MA plan or dropping MA to return to Original Medicare with a standalone Part D plan.
Why OEP Matters
The Opportunity
- Dissatisfied beneficiaries: Clients who enrolled during AEP and discovered their new plan does not meet expectations
- Competitor clients: Beneficiaries enrolled by other agents who are unhappy with their experience
- Missed AEP prospects: People who meant to change during AEP but never got around to it
The Math
If your AEP book includes 200 MA enrollments:
- 12-18% of MA enrollees make changes during OEP nationally
- That is 24-36 of your own clients who may be considering a change
- If you do not reach them first, another agent will
The OEP Playbook
Week 1-2 of January: Post-AEP Client Check-Ins
Contact every AEP enrollee to confirm:
- They received their new plan materials
- They understand their benefits, copays, and network
- Their prescriptions are covered under the new formulary
- Their doctors are in-network
This proactive outreach serves two purposes: it retains satisfied clients and identifies dissatisfied ones before they call another agent.
January: Proactive Problem Resolution
For clients reporting issues:
- Run new plan comparisons immediately
- Present alternatives that address their specific concerns
- Process OEP changes promptly — there is no second chance until next AEP
February-March: Competitive Prospecting
- Target Medicare Advantage beneficiaries in your area who are not your clients
- Focus messaging on plan dissatisfaction and switching ease
- Emphasize that OEP allows one plan change with no penalty
How unLocked CRM Supports OEP
Automated January Check-Ins: Workflows trigger post-enrollment satisfaction calls to every AEP client starting January 2.
Quick Re-Quoting: When a client reports dissatisfaction, pull up alternative plans instantly with the AI Quoting Suite.
Arwyn Captures OEP Inquiries: Beneficiaries searching for OEP help often call during business hours when you are in appointments. Arwyn captures their information and schedules callbacks.
Tracking Dashboard: Monitor which clients have been contacted, which reported issues, and which OEP changes have been processed.
From Experience
- The single most effective OEP tactic is calling every AEP enrollee in the first week of January — before they discover problems on their own and call another agent.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Medicare OEP?
The Open Enrollment Period runs January 1 through March 31. Medicare Advantage beneficiaries can make one plan change during this period.
Who can make changes during Medicare OEP?
Only Medicare Advantage enrollees can use OEP to switch to a different MA plan or drop MA and return to Original Medicare with a standalone Part D plan.