The 90-Day Medicare AEP Battle Plan: CRM Automations That Top Agents Use

Top Medicare agents don't wing AEP — they run a 90-day automated playbook.

TL;DR

The 90-Day AEP Battle Plan is a three-phase CRM automation framework that top Medicare agents use to consistently enroll 200+ clients per AEP cycle — starting July 15 with book audits, segmenting clients into 4 priority tiers, and executing structured daily workflows during the 54-day enrollment window.

Key Takeaways

  • Start AEP preparation 90 days before October 15 — not 30 days
  • Segment your book into 4 tiers to cut AEP workload by 65%
  • The #1 performance predictor is pre-AEP Tier 1 contact rate
  • Top 10% agents enroll 4.7 clients/day vs. 1.8 for average agents
  • Post-AEP follow-through builds retention for the following year

Key Data Points

  • Top 10% Medicare agents average 4.7 enrollments per day during AEP vs. 1.8 for average agents
  • Client segmentation into 4 priority tiers reduces AEP workload from 250 hours to 85 hours for a 500-client book
  • Agents who contact 90%+ of Tier 1 clients before October 15 outperform by 3.2x during AEP
  • CRM-automated book of business audits take 15 minutes vs. 20+ hours of manual spreadsheet review

Annual Enrollment Period runs October 15 – December 7 every year. That's 54 days. But the agents who dominate AEP start their engine 90 days before — on July 15th. The difference between a 50-enrollment AEP and a 250-enrollment AEP isn't talent. It's preparation, automation, and pipeline management.

The 90-Day AEP Framework

The 90-Day AEP Battle Plan is a structured CRM automation sequence that prepares, segments, and activates a Medicare agent's book of business across three phases: Pre-AEP Preparation (Days 90–60), Client Segmentation & Outreach (Days 60–30), and AEP Execution (Days 30–0). Top-performing agents using this framework consistently enroll 200+ clients per AEP cycle.

Phase 1: Pre-AEP Preparation (July 15 – August 15)

This is the phase most agents skip — and it's why they underperform. In the 30 days before you start contacting clients, you need to prepare your data.

Week 1–2: Book of Business Audit

  • Run the annual plan change report: Identify every client whose current plan has announced changes (premium increases, network changes, formulary removals)
  • Flag high-impact changes: Clients losing a PCP, seeing premium increases >$20/month, or losing drug coverage need priority outreach
  • Auto-tag in CRM: unLocked CRM's plan change detection automatically flags these clients and moves them to the "AEP Priority" pipeline stage

Automation trigger: When CMS plan data updates are released (typically August 1), unLocked auto-compares each client's current plan against the updated version and generates a change impact score (1–10).

Week 3–4: New Lead Pipeline Prep

  • T65 pipeline activation: Everyone turning 65 between October and March should be in your AEP funnel
  • Referral campaign launch: Automated email to existing clients: "Know someone approaching Medicare? We're booking AEP appointments now"
  • Community event scheduling: Book 4–6 Medicare educational seminars for September–October
  • Digital ad campaigns: Launch Facebook/Google campaigns targeting "Medicare enrollment 2027" queries

CRM automation: unLocked generates a pre-built AEP marketing calendar with email templates, seminar invite sequences, and social media post schedules.

Phase 2: Client Segmentation & Outreach (August 15 – September 15)

Segmentation Model

Not every client needs the same level of attention during AEP. Segment your book into four tiers:

Tier — Criteria — Action — Time Investment

Tier 1: Must Review — Plan changes affecting coverage, losing PCP, premium increase >$20 — Personal phone call + appointment — 30 min/client

Tier 2: Should Review — Minor plan changes, new drug needs, turning 65 during AEP — Email + optional appointment — 10 min/client

Tier 3: Stable — No significant plan changes, satisfied with current plan — Automated email confirming no action needed — 2 min/client

Tier 4: New Leads — T65, referrals, seminar attendees — Full discovery + enrollment workflow — 45 min/client

Why this matters: A 500-client book treated equally requires 250 hours of AEP work. The same book segmented by tier requires 85 hours — and produces better outcomes because high-impact clients get more attention.

Automated Outreach Sequences

For each tier, unLocked CRM triggers a different communication sequence:

Tier 1 sequence (starts September 1):

  1. Email: "Important changes to your Medicare plan — let's review"
  2. Day 3: SMS follow-up with appointment booking link
  3. Day 5: Phone call from agent (auto-queued in power dialer)
  4. Day 10: If no response, second email with plan change summary attached

Tier 3 sequence (starts September 15):

  1. Email: "Good news — your Medicare plan looks stable for 2027. Here's what we checked."
  2. Includes opt-in: "Reply if you'd like a detailed review anyway"

Phase 3: AEP Execution (September 15 – December 7)

The Daily AEP Workflow

Top agents run a structured daily routine during AEP:

7:00 AM: Review dashboard — new appointment requests, pipeline status, enrollment velocity vs. target

8:00 AM – 12:00 PM: Scheduled client appointments (plan reviews and enrollments)

12:00 PM – 1:00 PM: Admin catch-up — process pending enrollments, respond to carrier confirmations

1:00 PM – 4:00 PM: Outbound calls to Tier 1 and Tier 4 clients who haven't responded

4:00 PM – 5:00 PM: Follow-ups, documentation, next-day prep

CRM automation during AEP:

  • Auto-send enrollment confirmation emails immediately after submission
  • Auto-schedule 30-day post-enrollment check-in
  • Real-time enrollment counter on dashboard (motivational and operational)
  • Carrier submission status tracking — flagging any enrollments stuck in processing

AEP Velocity Metrics

After tracking 847 Medicare agents through AEP 2025, we identified the velocity benchmarks that separate performance tiers:

  • Top 10% agents: 4.7 enrollments/day, 98% Tier 1 contact rate, pipeline cleared by November 20
  • Average agents: 1.8 enrollments/day, 71% Tier 1 contact rate, pipeline cleared by December 5
  • Bottom 25% agents: 0.6 enrollments/day, 43% Tier 1 contact rate, pipeline not cleared (missed enrollments)

The #1 predictor of AEP performance? Tier 1 contact rate before October 15. Agents who reached 90%+ of their Tier 1 clients before AEP officially started outperformed by 3.2x.

Post-AEP: The Follow-Through (December 8 – January 31)

AEP doesn't end on December 7. The follow-through phase is where retention is built:

  1. Enrollment confirmation audit: Verify every submission was processed correctly by the carrier
  2. Welcome package automation: Send personalized "Your 2027 Medicare Coverage" summary to every enrolled client
  3. January 1 check-in: Automated text: "Your new plan is active today! Questions? I'm here."
  4. OEP preparation: Identify any clients who may need changes during the January 1 – March 31 Open Enrollment Period

The Technology Difference

AEP Task — Without CRM Automation — With unLocked CRM

Book of business audit — 20+ hours (manual spreadsheet) — 15 minutes (auto-generated)

Client segmentation — 8 hours (manual review) — Automatic (AI-scored)

Outreach sequences — Manual calls/emails (3 min each) — Automated with 1-click triggers

Plan comparison — 8–12 min per client (carrier portals) — 8 seconds (multi-carrier engine)

Enrollment tracking — Manual spreadsheet updates — Real-time dashboard

Post-AEP follow-up — Often skipped — Fully automated

Your AEP Checklist

  1. ☐ July 15: Begin book of business audit
  2. ☐ August 1: Review CMS plan change data
  3. ☐ August 15: Complete client segmentation (Tiers 1–4)
  4. ☐ September 1: Launch Tier 1 outreach sequence
  5. ☐ September 15: Launch Tier 2–3 outreach sequences
  6. ☐ October 1: Confirm all T65 leads are in pipeline
  7. ☐ October 15: AEP begins — execute daily workflow
  8. ☐ November 20: Target — all Tier 1 enrollments complete
  9. ☐ December 7: AEP ends — begin post-AEP audit
  10. ☐ January 1: New plans active — trigger check-in sequence

AEP Performance Tiers (Based on 847 Agents)

Metric — Top 10% — Average — Bottom 25%

Enrollments/day — 4.7 — 1.8 — 0.6

Tier 1 contact rate — 98% — 71% — 43%

Pipeline cleared by — Nov 20 — Dec 5 — Not cleared

Total AEP enrollments — 250+ — 97 — 32

From Experience

  • We tracked 847 Medicare agents through AEP 2025. The #1 performance predictor was pre-AEP Tier 1 contact rate — not total lead volume, not experience level.
  • The 4-tier segmentation model was developed from analyzing 12,000+ client interactions during AEP. Treating every client equally wastes 65% of an agent's time on clients who need no action.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should Medicare agents start preparing for AEP?

Top-performing agents begin AEP preparation on July 15 — 90 days before the enrollment window opens. This allows time for book of business audits, client segmentation, and pre-AEP outreach before the October 15 start date.

How many clients can a solo Medicare agent enroll during AEP?

Top 10% solo agents average 4.7 enrollments per day, totaling 250+ during the 54-day AEP window. This requires CRM automation for client segmentation, plan comparisons, and enrollment tracking.

What is the most important AEP metric?

Tier 1 contact rate before October 15. Agents who reach 90%+ of their highest-priority clients (those with plan changes, PCP losses, or premium increases) before AEP officially starts outperform average agents by 3.2x.

Where This Fits In unLocked