Side-by-side comparison of Facebook and Google ad costs for insurance leads — CPL, CPA, and ROI by line of business.
TL;DR
Facebook generates cheaper leads ($8–$25 CPL, lower intent). Google generates pricier leads ($25–$75 CPL, higher intent). A 70/30 Facebook/Google split optimizes blended ROI.
Key Takeaways
- Facebook: $8–$25 CPL, best for volume and final expense/Medicare
- Google: $25–$75 CPL, best for high-intent P&C and commercial
- 70/30 Facebook/Google split optimizes blended ROI
- Video ads on Facebook outperform static by 2x
- Long-tail keywords on Google reduce CPC by 70%
Facebook and Google are the two largest paid lead channels for insurance agents. They serve different purposes, have different cost structures, and require different strategies.
The Short Answer
Facebook generates cheaper leads ($8–$25 CPL) with lower intent. Google generates more expensive leads ($25–$75 CPL) with higher intent and close rates. For most agents, a 70/30 split favoring Facebook for volume and Google for high-intent produces the best blended ROI.
Facebook vs. Google Ads Comparison
| Metric | Facebook Ads | Google Ads |
|---|---|---|
| Average CPL | $8–$25 | $25–$75 |
| Lead Intent | Low–Medium | High |
| Close Rate | 8–15% | 12–20% |
| Cost Per Acquisition | $60–$200 | $150–$400 |
| Best For | Volume, final expense, Medicare | P&C, commercial, high-intent searches |
| Targeting | Demographics, interests, lookalikes | Search intent, keywords |
| Creative Required | Video/image ads | Text ads (+ landing pages) |
| Learning Curve | Medium | High |
Facebook Ads for Insurance: What Works
- Video ads outperform static by 2x — 30-second "did you know" format works best
- Lead forms > landing pages — Native Facebook lead forms reduce CPL by 30–40%
- Lookalike audiences — Upload your client list and target similar profiles
- Retargeting — People who visited your site but didn't convert are 3x more likely to close
Google Ads for Insurance: What Works
- Long-tail keywords — "life insurance for diabetics in Texas" costs 70% less than "life insurance"
- Local service ads — Pay per lead, not per click. $15–$40 per lead with high intent
- Landing page optimization — Custom pages with instant quote forms convert 3x generic pages
- Negative keywords — Exclude "free", "cheap", and competitor brand terms to improve quality
Track every ad lead through your pipeline with unLocked CRM — automatic source attribution, CPL tracking, and ROI reporting by channel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Facebook or Google ads better for insurance leads?
Both serve different purposes. Facebook is better for volume and awareness ($8–$25 CPL). Google is better for high-intent leads ($25–$75 CPL, 12–20% close rate). Most agents benefit from a 70/30 split.
How much should insurance agents spend on ads?
Start with $500–$1,000/month on Facebook to test and optimize. Scale to $2,000–$5,000/month once you have a positive ROI. Add Google at $1,000+/month for high-intent supplement.