The 10 KPIs Every Insurance Agent Should Track

What gets measured gets improved. Here are the metrics that matter most for insurance sales success.

Flying blind is no way to run an insurance practice. These ten KPIs give you the visibility to improve continuously.

1. Lead Response Time

How quickly do you respond to new leads? Under 5 minutes is the gold standard.

2. Contact Rate

What percentage of leads do you actually reach? Track this by channel (call, text, email).

3. Appointment Set Rate

Of contacts reached, how many result in scheduled appointments?

4. Quote Rate

What percentage of appointments convert to quote requests?

5. Close Rate

Of quotes issued, how many become policies?

6. Average Premium

What's the average size of policies you close?

7. Activities Per Day

Total calls, emails, and texts. Activity drives results.

8. Pipeline Value

Total potential premium in your active pipeline.

9. Sales Cycle Length

Average days from first contact to closed policy.

10. Persistency Rate

What percentage of policies renew? This affects long-term income.