Insurance Agency Valuation: Book of Business Multiples in 2026

What's your insurance book worth? 2026 valuation multiples by product line, revenue type, and retention rate — with a free calculator.

Whether you're planning to sell, buy, or simply understand the value you're building, knowing your agency's valuation is essential. Insurance book valuations are driven by predictable factors — and the multiples have shifted significantly in the 2024–2026 market.

The Short Answer

Insurance books of business typically sell for 1.5x–3.0x annual revenue, depending on product line, retention rate, and revenue type. Health/Medicare books command 2.0x–3.0x due to recurring renewals. Life books sell at 1.0x–2.0x due to front-loaded commissions. The single biggest valuation driver is client retention rate — every 5% improvement in retention increases valuation by 0.3x–0.5x.

2026 Valuation Multiples

Product LineLow MultipleMedian MultipleHigh Multiple
P&C (personal lines)1.8x2.2x3.0x
P&C (commercial)2.0x2.5x3.5x
Group benefits2.0x2.8x3.5x
Medicare (MA/Supp)2.0x2.5x3.0x
Life (term)1.0x1.5x2.0x
Life (permanent/UL)1.5x2.0x2.5x
Annuities1.5x2.0x2.8x
ACA/Health1.5x2.0x2.5x

What Drives Higher Valuations

  • Retention rate above 90% — The #1 valuation factor
  • Recurring revenue concentration — Renewal-heavy books command premiums
  • Diversified product mix — Multi-line agencies are less risky for buyers
  • Clean data and systems — A CRM with complete client records adds 0.2x–0.5x to valuation
  • Young client base — Longer expected lifetime value
  • Low producer concentration — Revenue spread across multiple agents, not one star producer

What Reduces Valuations

  • ❌ Retention below 82% (raises red flags about service quality)
  • ❌ Revenue concentrated in one producer (key-person risk)
  • ❌ Paper files / no CRM (integration costs for buyer)
  • ❌ Single-carrier dependency
  • ❌ Declining revenue trend

Building Value with CRM

A well-maintained CRM directly increases your book's valuation by:

  • Documenting client relationships and communication history
  • Proving retention rates with data
  • Enabling smooth transition to a buyer
  • Tracking commission history for revenue verification
  • Maintaining household-level records that demonstrate cross-sell density

Use our Buy-Sell Calculator to estimate your book's value.

FAQs

Can I sell part of my book?
Yes — it's common to sell a specific product line or geographic segment. Medicare books and group benefits books are frequently sold independently.
How long does an insurance book sale take?
Typically 3–6 months from listing to close. Having clean CRM data and organized financials can cut this to 6–10 weeks.