The 12 metrics that separate thriving agencies from struggling ones — and how to track them automatically.
TL;DR
12 essential KPIs span revenue (premium, renewal rate, revenue/agent, commission/policy), activity (quotes, quote-to-bind, speed-to-quote, appointments), and client metrics (retention, policies/client, NPS, CAC).
Key Data Points
- Healthy insurance agencies produce $150K–$250K revenue per agent annually
- Best-in-class speed-to-quote is under 2 hours; AI achieves under 5 minutes
- Insurance client retention target is 92%+ annually
12 Insurance Agency KPIs Every Owner Should Track
Revenue KPIs
- New Business Premium — Target 5–10% monthly growth. 2. Renewal Rate — Target 85%+, 90%+ for commercial. 3. Revenue Per Agent — Benchmark $150K–$250K annually. 4. Commission Per Policy — Track by product line.
Activity KPIs
- Quotes Per Agent — 15–25/week. 6. Quote-to-Bind Ratio — 30–40% personal, 20–30% commercial. 7. Speed to Quote — Best-in-class under 2 hours; AI achieves under 5 min. 8. Appointments/Week — 8–12 per producer.
Client KPIs
- Retention Rate — Target 92%+. 10. Policies Per Client — Target 2.5+. 11. NPS — 50+ excellent, 70+ world-class. 12. Client Acquisition Cost — Under $200 personal lines.
unLocked CRM tracks all 12 automatically with real-time dashboards.
Frequently Asked Questions
What KPIs should insurance agencies track?
12 KPIs across Revenue, Activity, and Client categories — from new business premium to NPS to client acquisition cost.
What is a good quote-to-bind ratio?
30–40% for personal lines, 20–30% for commercial. Below these benchmarks indicates pricing, presentation, or lead quality issues.