How to handle health insurance premium increases with clients: flag above 10%, re-shop in advance, compare on total cost.
TL;DR
Health clients leave over surprise, not over price. Flag increases above 10% early, re-shop before contact, compare on total expected cost rather than premium alone, and give a written recommendation.
Key Takeaways
- Total expected cost — premium plus expected utilization — is the honest comparison.
- Flag material increases above 10% and work them by revenue at risk.
- Deliver options before the notice letter, not after.
- Sometimes the right recommendation is to stay; say it in writing and earn the next renewal.
Key Data Points
- Health insurance retention improves when agents flag rate increases above 10% early and compare on total expected cost rather than premium alone.
Health Insurance Cost Increases: The Retention Playbook
Clients rarely leave because a premium went up. They leave because a premium went up and nobody warned them.
Step 1: See it first
Renewal automation flags increases above 10% with revenue at risk attached. Work the list by revenue, not by date.
Step 2: Re-shop before the call
Arrive with alternatives. unLocked CRM quotes across 1,139 health carrier integrations, so a re-shop is minutes rather than an afternoon of portals.
Step 3: Compare on total expected cost
Premium is one line. The honest comparison is:
- Premium (net of subsidy for marketplace clients)
- Deductible and MOOP
- Copays and coinsurance for the care they actually use
- Drug tiers for their actual medications
- Network status of their actual doctors
A cheaper premium with a worse formulary is a more expensive year. Say so.
Step 4: Give a recommendation in writing
"I recommend X because Y." Clients pay for judgment. A table without a recommendation makes them do your job, and then they wonder what they need you for.
Step 5: Include the option to stay
Sometimes the current plan is still the best fit. Saying that out loud, after demonstrably re-shopping, is the highest-trust move available to an agent — and it is exactly what a comparison website cannot do.
Step 6: Deliver instantly and follow up automatically
Send the comparison by SMS and email during the call. Attach the remainder to sequences and AI outbound calling so no one falls out of the window in silence.
Frequently Asked Questions
How should agents present a premium increase?
Lead with the work already done: the increase, the alternatives you re-shopped, and a written recommendation. Never let the notice letter be the first contact.
Should you compare on premium alone?
No. Compare on total expected cost — premium, deductible, copays, and expected utilization — plus network and formulary fit.
What triggers a proactive re-shop?
Rate increases above 10%, formulary or network changes affecting the client, or a change in the client's health or household.