A timeline-based commercial renewal workflow used by top P&C agencies — 90-day exposure update, 60-day market submission, 30-day binding, with retention math.
TL;DR
Commercial P&C renewals should run on a 90-60-30 day clock: 90 days out for exposure update and stewardship meeting, 60 days out for market submission and quote analysis, 30 days out for binding and certificates. Agencies that hold the 90-60-30 cadence retain 90–94% of commercial business; agencies that scramble in the last 30 days retain 75–82%.
Key Takeaways
- Run commercial renewals on a 90-60-30 day clock — start at 120 days for accounts over $25,000 premium.
- Stewardship meetings at 90 days improve retention by 8–12 percentage points.
- Submit to 3–5 quality markets, not 10 blast submissions.
- Mid-year check-ins surface exposure changes and cross-sell opportunities.
Key Data Points
- Commercial P&C renewal retention drops 12–18 percentage points when the agent waits until the last 30 days to start the renewal cycle.
- Top-quartile commercial agencies start renewal workflow at 120 days out for accounts over $25,000 in premium.
- Stewardship meetings at 90 days out improve renewal retention by 8–12 percentage points vs no stewardship.
Commercial P&C renewals are not personal lines renewals. The premium is higher, the underwriting is deeper, and the client expects you to actively manage the account — not just rubber-stamp last year's policy.
The agencies that retain 90%+ of commercial business run the 90-60-30 day clock religiously. Here's the playbook.
120 Days Out (Large Accounts)
For accounts over $25,000 in premium, start at 120:
- Schedule stewardship meeting
- Request updated financials, payroll, sales projections
- Identify exposure changes (new locations, new equipment, M&A activity)
90 Days Out: Exposure Update + Stewardship
- Send exposure update questionnaire to client.
- Schedule stewardship meeting. In-person preferred.
- Review prior year claims activity with client.
- Identify coverage gaps and recommend updates.
- Pull loss runs from incumbent carrier.
60 Days Out: Market Submission
- Update SOV (Schedule of Values) for property accounts.
- Update vehicle schedule for auto accounts.
- Update payroll/sales for workers comp and GL.
- Submit to 3–5 markets (don't blast — quality submissions).
- Provide a marketing report to the client showing markets approached.
30 Days Out: Binding
- Collect quotes. Build a renewal proposal showing premium, terms, and coverage comparison.
- Meet with client (or video call) to present renewal options.
- Bind coverage. Issue certificates as needed.
- Confirm carrier received accord premium audit forms if applicable.
Day of Renewal
- Issue ID cards, certificates, autoland bond riders, whatever the client needs.
- Schedule mid-term check-in at 6 months.
Mid-Year (6 Months Post-Renewal)
- Reach out for mid-year exposure update.
- Identify cross-sell opportunities.
- Update CRM with any exposure changes.
Retention Math
Workflow — Retention — Premium Lost on $1M Book
90-60-30 cadence — 90–94% — $60,000–$100,000
30-day scramble — 75–82% — $180,000–$250,000
No structured workflow — 65–75% — $250,000–$350,000
The 90-60-30 cadence is the highest-ROI workflow in commercial P&C. Most agencies don't run it consistently — that's the opportunity.
What Top Agencies Track in the CRM
- Renewal date + 120/90/60/30 day milestones as automated tasks
- Stewardship meeting completed (yes/no)
- Loss runs ordered (yes/no)
- Markets approached + quote received
- Binding confirmed + certificates issued
- Mid-year check-in scheduled
Every commercial account, every year, the same workflow.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why 90-60-30 instead of 60-30-15?
Commercial underwriting takes longer than personal lines. 60 days for market submission is tight for accounts with complex exposures. 90 days gives carriers time to underwrite properly.
Is stewardship really worth it?
Yes. Stewardship meetings at 90 days out improve renewal retention by 8–12 percentage points. On a $1M book, that's $80,000–$120,000 of preserved premium.
How many markets should I submit to?
3–5 quality submissions beats 10 blast submissions. Underwriters notice when a submission is competitive vs spray-and-pray.