AEP & OEP Calling: Why Answer Rates Drop 40% During Enrollment and How to Fix It

During AEP and OEP, every insurance agent calls Medicare clients simultaneously — crashing answer rates.

TL;DR

AEP answer rates drop 40-50% as clients are overwhelmed. Call Identity AI maintains 35%+ rates during enrollment — agents with branding achieve 2-3x more enrollments during AEP.

Key Data Points

  • AEP answer rates: 6-7% for unverified numbers vs. 35%+ with Call Identity AI
  • Medicare clients receive 12-20 calls/week during AEP from competing agents
  • Agent with Call Identity AI: 127 → 341 AEP enrollments (168% increase) same book, same volume

The Short Answer

During Medicare AEP (Oct 15 – Dec 7) and OEP (Jan 1 – Mar 31), answer rates drop 40-50% as clients are overwhelmed with calls from multiple agents and carriers. Agents using Call Identity AI maintain 35%+ answer rates during enrollment because branded calls with business name display stand out from the flood of unknown numbers. This translates to 2-3x more enrollments during the same period.

The AEP Answer Rate Crisis

During AEP, a typical Medicare-eligible client receives:

  • 12–20 calls per week from insurance agents
  • 5–10 direct mail pieces per week
  • 15+ digital ads per day

The natural response: stop answering the phone. Answer rates during AEP drop from the normal 11% to 6-7% for unverified numbers. But clients still answer calls from numbers they recognize — which is why branded calling matters most during enrollment.

Pre-AEP Preparation

  1. 60 days before AEP: Register all numbers you'll use during enrollment
  2. 30 days before: Send VCF contact cards to your Medicare book
  3. Week of AEP: Begin branded outreach — your name displays while competitors show "Unknown"
  4. During AEP: Monitor reputation daily — high volume can trigger spam flags even on registered numbers

AEP Calling Results

A Medicare-focused agent compared their AEP results before and after Call Identity AI. Before (AEP 2024): 11% answer rate in October, dropped to 6% by late November. 127 enrollments. After (AEP 2025): Started at 38%, maintained 35% through November with branded calling and pre-delivered VCF cards. 341 enrollments — a 168% increase with the same size book and same call volume.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do answer rates drop during AEP?

Medicare-eligible clients receive 12-20 calls/week during AEP from multiple agents. They stop answering unknown numbers. Branded calls with your business name display still get answered.

How early should I prepare for AEP calling?

Start 60 days before: register numbers, send VCF contact cards 30 days before, and monitor reputation daily during AEP to catch spam flags early.