Medicare agents see 3-4x call volume during AEP. Hiring temps costs $3,000-$8,000 for the season. Arwyn handles the overflow at no additional cost.
TL;DR
Medicare AEP call volume spikes 3-4x, and agents miss 38% of calls during appointments. Arwyn captures 95% of overflow calls during AEP, recovering approximately $146,880 in lifetime enrollment revenue — without hiring temporary staff ($3,000-$8,000/season).
Key Data Points
- Medicare call volume spikes 3-4x during AEP, with peak days in the first and last weeks of the enrollment period.
- Missed AEP calls cost agents $129,744 in lost lifetime enrollment revenue — Arwyn recovers $146,880 by capturing 95% of overflow.
AEP is the Super Bowl of Medicare sales. Call volume spikes 3-4x from mid-October through early December. Every unanswered call during AEP is a potential enrollment lost — not just for this year, but for every renewal year afterward.
The AEP Call Volume Problem
The Spike
- Normal weekly call volume: 15-25 inbound calls
- AEP weekly call volume: 45-100+ inbound calls
- Peak days: First week of AEP and final week before December 7
- Busiest hours: 9-11 AM and 1-3 PM
Why Calls Spike
- Beneficiaries receiving ANOC (Annual Notice of Change) letters call their agent
- Prospects responding to AEP marketing campaigns
- Referrals from existing clients
- Competitors' clients looking for alternatives
- Community seminar attendees with follow-up questions
The Staffing Dilemma
Option 1: Hire Temporary Staff
- Cost: $3,000-$8,000 for the 54-day AEP period
- Training time: 1-2 weeks (eating into AEP itself)
- Quality: Inconsistent — temps lack insurance knowledge
- Availability: Good temps are hard to find during AEP (every agency wants them)
Option 2: Ignore the Overflow
- Cost: $0 upfront
- Lost revenue: $50,000-$200,000+ in missed enrollments
- Competitor advantage: Lost callers enroll with other agents
Option 3: Arwyn
- Cost: $0 additional
- Training: Already insurance-trained
- Quality: Consistent, qualified responses
- Availability: Unlimited capacity, 24/7
How Arwyn Handles AEP Overflow
During Appointment Blocks
You are in back-to-back Medicare reviews from 9 AM to 5 PM. Every call that arrives during an appointment:
- Arwyn answers professionally
- Identifies the caller's Medicare situation (new to Medicare, plan change, Medigap question)
- Captures current coverage details and plan concerns
- Qualifies the enrollment urgency
- Books an appointment in your next available slot
- Sends confirmation to the caller
- Creates a pipeline entry with all captured information
Between Appointments
During your 5-10 minute breaks, you check the Arwyn dashboard:
- 3 new qualified Medicare leads captured
- 2 appointments booked for later this week
- 1 existing client with a plan question (task created)
- All information logged in CRM — no data entry needed
After Hours During AEP
AEP anxiety drives calls at all hours:
- Beneficiaries who just received their ANOC call at 7 PM
- Adult children researching Medicare options for parents at 9 PM
- Weekend callers who want to book Monday appointments
Arwyn handles all of it. You wake up to booked appointments and qualified leads.
The AEP Math
Without Arwyn (38% missed calls)
- 80 AEP calls/week × 38% missed = 30 missed calls/week
- 85% voicemail abandonment = 25.5 lost leads/week
- 7 AEP weeks × 25.5 = 178 lost leads over AEP
- 30% would-have-enrolled = 53 lost enrollments
- At $306 renewal commission × 8-year retention = $129,744 in lost lifetime revenue
With Arwyn (95% capture)
- Same 30 overflow calls/week × 95% captured = 28.5 captured/week
- 7 weeks × 28.5 = 199 captured leads
- 30% enrollment rate = 60 additional enrollments
- Lifetime revenue: $146,880 recovered
The difference is not just this year's commissions — it is 8+ years of renewals from every client Arwyn helped you capture.
From Experience
- The agents who capture the most AEP enrollments are not the ones who work the longest hours — they are the ones who never miss a call, even when they are in appointments.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does AEP call volume increase?
Medicare agents typically see 3-4x normal call volume during AEP (October 15 – December 7), with peak days generating 5-6x normal volume.
How do you handle overflow calls during AEP?
Options: hire temps ($3,000-$8,000/season), ignore overflow (losing $50,000-$200,000+), or use Arwyn AI to capture and qualify overflow calls at no additional cost.